
Journalists are supposed to challenge claims, demand evidence, and pursue the truth regardless of who’s speaking. But fears surrounding identity politics have turned mainstream news agencies into echo chambers where activists go unchecked -- as long as they’re pushing the newsroom’s preferred agenda.
In the new episode, I’m joined by David Christopher Kaufman. He’s a fellow former journalist for news giants, including The New York Times. Now, he’s founder of The Octagon Project fighting extremism. He explains how “aggrievement culture” broke journalism.
“Once you start invoking this language of identity politics, it immediately resets the entire equation. Very few media will push back against you because they're afraid of being called racist, they're afraid of their 24-year-old social media managers rebelling, and also because most of the folks who would push back are white and simply are not sophisticated enough in the fluency of identity politics to actually have the grasp and the language to say, ‘This is not true.’”
In this episode:
‘Illogical, woe-is-me’ narratives: Why Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed’s interview with Hasan Minhaj captures a culture that rewards victimhood over accomplishment.
The Know-Nothing Experts: The Bizarro World-level madness of newsrooms treating Ta-Nehisi Coates as an authority on Israel.
Dangerous Double Standards: From downplaying NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s college application controversy to demanding Jews “prove” they’re unsafe.
‘Movement Mooching’: Kaufman—who is Black, gay, and Jewish—says media narratives about Black-Jewish alliances and Black-Palestinian “solidarity” ignore reality.
Plus, I fact-check claims about police shootings, cite same-sex marriage polling, and explain how the models for making truth-telling possible have revolutionized.

Paid subscribers: Share thoughts, questions, and more in the comments or messages.


