For David Christopher Kaufman, it wasn’t the October 7 massacres that inspired him to create a new organization. It was the next day.
While Hamas terrorists were “marauding through southern Israel, slaughtering, raping, kidnapping Jews and non-Jews,” he says, there was a “massive, reflexive reaction of progressive groups who issued this decree that October 7 was basically entirely the fault of Israel. And so many of them did this in sort of the name of Black and brown people and queer people. And I was like, ‘I’m a Black and brown person. I’m a queer person. And these people absolutely do not speak for me.’”
He has now launched The Octagon Project (the name refers to October 8), which takes on anti-Western and antisemitic extremism “through the lens of civil rights.” In our wide-ranging interview for the latest episode of They Stand Corrected, the proudly Black, gay, Jewish, Zionist independent journalist explains how the media allows bigoted activists to use their own minority status to present a warped view of Israel and Jewish history.
Edited transcripts are an exclusive perk for paid subscribers. Here’s a taste:
David: There’s a hierarchy of privilege, of entitlement, of accomplishment. On one level, Jews are considered at the top. That is why they’re so demonized. But at the other level, they’re considered at the bottom. They’re worthy of no agency and must, as a consequence, compensate. They must pay back. They must be diminished because of their supposed whiteness, because of their supposed privilege, because of their supposed supremacy. And any conversation that frames Jews in a racialized lens will always be to the detriment of Jews, and is always a pathway towards apologizing for violence against Jews.
Josh: It’s always whatever the bad thing is. To the white supremacists, we are the least white people. To the AZHM (antizionist hate movement) people, we are the most white people. It used to be bad to be poor. So Jews were, “You poor Jew, selling your fruits on the street corner.” Now it’s bad to be rich, so Jews are the richest. There’s a constant re-categorizing. People pulling the strings — these giant hate groups — know how to use those categorizations. And the media takes that and runs with it.
David: Yeah. But also the problem is that Jews have been bamboozled into reflexively responding in a way that only works against them. So the moment you start accusing Jews of being white, the first thing that they’ll say is, “What about Sephardic Jews? What about Mizrahi Jews? What about Ethiopian Jews? What about the vast percentage of Jews in Israel who are not white?”
I don’t have those conversations. I reframe the entire conversation. What is your motivation? Why does it matter what color Jews are? Nothing you say will ever be enough for these people. There’s nothing you can do to satisfy their craven desire for bloodlust. So don’t bother.
Listen to the full interview now. Paid subscribers: Share your thoughts and questions below.


